Lab-leak theory half-truths, misrepresentations, and tendentious conjecture: says media

2021-06-11 18:02来源: GMW.cn

调查问题加载中,请稍候。
若长时间无响应,请刷新本页面

Months after a WHO-convened global study reported it "extremely unlikely" that the novel coronavirus spread from a lab leak in Wuhan, China, the so-called lab-leak theory was hyped up with a Wall Street Journal report alleging that three researchers from China's Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) fell sick in November 2019 and sought hospital care. However, not only were the sources dubious by citing a so-called "previously undisclosed U.S. intelligence report", the evidence of the article was deemed untenable and politically driven by the scientific community.

"The evidence right now, well, for the lab side, it's political: It's from an intel agency that's not been shown. That's not scientific," said Peter Daszak, zoologist and member of the WHO-led team investigating the origins of Covid-19, during a recent virologist podcast. "It's not something that you can really reasonably launch a major audit of."

Another team member speaking alongside Daszak, Danish epidemiologist Thea Fischer pointed out that in the absence of any new evidence pointing to a lab accident, the investigation should focus on the main hypothesis - that the virus spilled naturally from animals to humans, outside a laboratory.

"Nothing's really tipped me or made me flip-flop or anything about it," said Robert Garry, a microbiologist at Tulane University who has analyzed the genome of the virus, as cited by National Public Radio (NPR) on May 28. "I'm more convinced than ever that this is a natural virus."

Lab-leak theory half-truths, misrepresentations, and tendentious conjecture: says media

Lab-leak theory half-truths, misrepresentations, and tendentious conjecture: says media

Screenshot of NPR report "Many Scientists Still Think The Coronavirus Came From Nature", published on May 28, 2021

Ian Lipkin, another researcher from the Mailman School of Public Health at Columbia University also disbelieved the virus a lab leak result and said that there's no evidence for human manipulation, according to NPR.

Even scientists who signed Relman's letter in Science calling for further investigations into the origins of COVID-19 have voiced opinions. Some emphasized that they are not endorsing the lab-leak theory and are highly skeptical of the lab leak hypothesis.

Lab-leak theory half-truths, misrepresentations, and tendentious conjecture: says media

Screenshot of Nature research report "Divisive COVID ‘lab leak’ debate prompts dire warnings from researchers", published on May 27, 2021

"I am not saying I believe the virus came from a laboratory," said the organizer of the letter, David Relman of Stanford, in a Nature research report on May 27.Another signatory, Ralph S. Baric of the University of North Carolina, told the New Yorker, "The genetic sequence for SARS-CoV-2 really points to a natural-origin event from wildlife."

Russian virologist and expert at the World Health Organization Dmitry Lvov also ruled out the man-made origin of the virus, saying that the concerns over the artificial origins of COVID-19 do not have any value.

Lab-leak theory half-truths, misrepresentations, and tendentious conjecture: says media

Screen grab from footage released by Russia-24 news channel shows that Russian virologist and WHO expert Dmitry Lvov is being interviewed on May 29, 2021.

"Coronaviruses are primarily viruses associated with bats. Someone could have been infected either in a room where a bat spent the night or in a cave where bats usually live in large numbers," Lvov said in a Russian television program on May 29.

He added that roughly 150 viruses have been transmitted to humans from animals during the domestication of wild animals, and further suggested other possibilities such as a person could have eaten some meat from animals that have ecological ties with bats, thus becoming the first source of infections.

An L.A. Times columnist refuted the triggering May 23 article in Wall Street Journal, saying there was no evidence that the three researchers had contracted COVID-19 as opposed to flu or any other virus.

Lab-leak theory half-truths, misrepresentations, and tendentious conjecture: says media

Screenshot of Los Angeles Times column "The lab-leak origin claim for COVID-19 is in the news, nut it's still fact-free", published on June 3, 2021

The writer, Michael Hiltzik contended that there was no evidence - not a smidgen - for the claim that COVID-19 originated in a laboratory in China or anywhere else, or that the China lab ever had the virus in its inventory. "There's even less for the wildest version of the claim, which is that the virus was deliberately engineered. There never has been, and there isn't now."

"What remained of the lab-leak theory was half-truths, misrepresentations, and tendentious conjecture."

The hypothesis, said Hiltzik, was touted by ideologically suspect promoters of falsehoods, whose lies had often been targeted at China for political reasons, aiming to paint China as an untrustworthy economic and political actor, according to L.A. Times.

[责任编辑: GSY ]
阅读剩余全文(
为你推荐
于无声处听惊雷——中共一大百年回望
16
神舟十二号飞行任务乘组:聂海胜(中)、刘伯明(右)、汤洪波(左)。 新华社发(徐部 摄)。
16
4月26日,2021上海合作组织国际投资贸易博览会暨上海合作组织地方经贸合作青岛论坛在青岛开幕,这是与会嘉宾在博览会上参观。
15
经文化和旅游部数据中心测算,2021年端午节假期三天,全国国内旅游出游8913.6万人次。
15
端午节临近,各地举行丰富多彩的民俗文化活动,迎接传统佳节的到来。
14
6月13日,农民驾驶收割机在河北省衡水市阜城县崔家庙镇前砖门村麦田开展夏收作业。
14
6月12日18时许,盈江县发生5.0级地震,据云南省地震台网测定,震中在北纬24.96度、东经97.89度,震源深度16千米,宏观震中位于勐弄乡一带,盈江县城震感强烈。
13
6月12日,广东省召开疫情防控工作视频会议,部署集中优势资源、优势力量,全省全市调度、统筹指挥,全力打好广州荔湾区白鹤洞街疫情防控攻坚战。连日来,荔湾区白鹤洞街、中南街等中高风险区开展了多轮全员核酸检测。
13
中国政府援建的中斯友好暨斯里兰卡国家肾内专科医院(简称中斯友好医院)11日在位于斯中部的波隆纳鲁沃正式启用。中国政府援建的中斯友好暨斯里兰卡国家肾内专科医院(简称中斯友好医院)11日在位于斯中部的波隆纳鲁沃正式启用。
12
当天,包括芝加哥在内的美国伊利诺伊州解除疫情管制,全面开放。当天,包括芝加哥在内的美国伊利诺伊州解除疫情管制,全面开放。当天,包括芝加哥在内的美国伊利诺伊州解除疫情管制,全面开放。
12
第27届上海电视节10日晚落下帷幕,白玉兰奖揭晓。于和伟、童瑶凭借在《觉醒年代》《三十而已》中的优异表现,分获最佳男女主角奖。于和伟、童瑶凭借在《觉醒年代》《三十而已》中的优异表现,分获最佳男女主角奖。
11
中国土木工程集团有限公司(中土集团)承建的尼日利亚拉伊铁路10日在拉各斯举行通车仪式。新华社发(埃玛·休斯敦摄)  6月10日,尼日利亚总统布哈里(前排左三)在拉各斯的莫博拉吉·约翰逊火车站出席拉伊铁路通车仪式并揭牌。
11
6月9日,神舟十二号载人飞船与长征二号F遥十二运载火箭组合体正在转运至发射区。据中国载人航天工程办公室消息,北京时间2021年6月9日,神舟十二号载人飞船与长征二号F遥十二运载火箭组合体已转运至发射区。
10
鉴于当前新冠疫情进一步缓解,比利时当天启动“夏季计划”第一阶段,餐馆、咖啡馆、酒吧等恢复室内营业。鉴于当前新冠疫情进一步缓解,比利时当天启动“夏季计划”第一阶段,餐馆、咖啡馆、酒吧等恢复室内营业。
10
6月8日,在位于纽约的联合国总部,爱沙尼亚常驻联合国代表斯文·于尔根松宣读安理会声明。联合国安理会成员8日以鼓掌方式一致通过决议,决定向联合国大会推荐古特雷斯连任联合国秘书长,任期自2022年1月1日至2026年12月31日。
09
6月8日,马匹在甘肃省定西市岷县境内的狼渡草原上吃草饮水(无人机照片)。初夏时节,位于甘肃省定西市岷县境内的狼渡草原披上绿装,牛马成群,空气清新,吸引了众多游客。初夏时节,位于甘肃省定西市岷县境内的狼渡草原披上绿装,牛马成群,空气清新,吸引了众多游客。
09
记者从云南北迁亚洲象群安全防范工作省级指挥部了解到,截至6月7日16时50分,象群持续在昆明市晋宁区夕阳彝族乡小范围原地休息徘徊,暂停迁移。记者从云南北迁亚洲象群安全防范工作省级指挥部了解到,截至6月7日16时50分,象群持续在昆明市晋宁区夕阳彝族乡小范围原地休息徘徊,暂停迁移。
08
6月7日,阿西米·戈伊塔(前)在马里首都巴马科宣誓就任马里过渡总统后向国旗致敬。阿西米·戈伊塔7日在马里首都巴马科正式宣誓就任马里过渡总统。阿西米·戈伊塔7日在马里首都巴马科正式宣誓就任马里过渡总统。
08
6月7日,老师在内蒙古呼和浩特市第二中学(西校区)考点门口鼓励考生。新华社记者 贝赫 摄  6月7日,考生在北京市陈经纶中学排队进入考场。新华社记者 肖艺九 摄  6月7日,考生在北京市陈经纶中学考点排队进入考场。
07
载入更多资讯
返回
返回

点击右上角微信好友

朋友圈

点击浏览器下方“”分享微信好友Safari浏览器请点击“”按钮

点击右上角QQ

点击浏览器下方“”分享QQ好友Safari浏览器请点击“”按钮